By Adrian Middleton · Tuesday, November 17, 2026
The rule most insured employers have never read
Section 440.107(2), Florida Statutes, defines securing compensation as obtaining coverage that meets the requirements of Chapter 440 and the Insurance Code. Then it adds the sentence that produces stop-work orders on insured companies: if at any time an employer materially understates or conceals payroll, materially misrepresents or conceals employee duties to avoid proper classification, or materially misrepresents or conceals information pertinent to the experience rating modification factor, the employer shall be deemed to have failed to secure the payment of workers' compensation.
Deemed. The policy stays in force for an injured worker. For section 440.107 purposes it is as if the policy never existed.
The three triggers
- Understated payroll. The policy is written on $80,000 of estimated payroll and the bank records show $600,000 of labor payments. Cash from job draws. Checks cashed at a check-cashing store so the payroll never reaches a 941 or an RT-6. Labor run through a "subcontractor" entity the employer controls.
- Misclassified duties. Framers reported as clerical. A roofing company whose policy shows $40,000 of office payroll and $2 million of permits. The rate for roofing is many times the rate for clerical, and the gap is premium the carrier never received.
- Experience mod concealment. Information bearing on the experience rating factor that was misrepresented or withheld.
The common thread is a gap between what the carrier was told and what actually happened. The gap is the case.
Why it is worse than having no policy
- The lookback doubles. Section 440.107(7)(d)1 extends the penalty period from the preceding 12 months to the preceding 24 months when the order is issued for materially understating or concealing payroll. Same formula, twice the period.
- The criminal statute is specific. Section 440.105(4)(b)6 makes knowingly misrepresenting or concealing payroll or classification to reduce premium insurance fraud, and (4)(b)5 covers false statements made to obtain coverage or avoid premium. These orders are the ones most likely to be referred to the Division of Investigative and Forensic Services; I worked those referrals, including the large check-cashing schemes.
- The carrier is now a witness. The carrier runs its own premium audit, re-rates the policy on the real payroll and codes, bills the back premium and may cancel. Section 440.105(1)(a) requires carriers to report suspected fraud to the Department, and audit findings are routinely shared.
How the Department proves it
The investigator compares the policy payroll to everything else: bank deposits and disbursements, 1099s, permits pulled, square footage built, the number of workers on site and what they say about tenure and pay. In a section 440.107(2) case the records decision is harder than usual. Producing records produces the proof of the gap. Declining produces imputation for every identified worker over 24 months, at $2,036.93 a week for 2026 orders, and an inference. Neither is survivable without a strategy, and the strategy is built with the criminal exposure on the same page.
What "material" means
The statute does not define it. In practice the Department treats any understatement large enough to change the premium meaningfully as material, and it does not accept rounding or an agent's estimate as the explanation for a gap of tens of thousands of dollars. "I reported what my agent told me to report" matters to whether the understatement was knowing, which is the criminal question, and to materiality. It does not change the formula. Preserve every message with the agent.
If you are insured and worried
The conversation to have is with counsel, before the carrier's auditor or the Department's investigator arrives, because that conversation is privileged and theirs is not. The underreported payroll page and the misclassification page cover the two halves of the rule; the causes page puts it next to the other four triggers.
Insured and served anyway, or about to be audited? Call or text (850) 766-6825. Free consultation, 24/7.
If you have been served
The deadlines start running as soon as the paperwork is served. Start here.
